The depicts of an alleged conspiracy between the popular online chess platform and Carlsen to bar Niemann from professional competition in retaliation for Niemann’s defeat of Carlsen, the world’s No. 1 player, last month at the St. Louis-based Sinquefield Cup.
Niemann “brings this action to recover from the devastating damages that Defendants have inflicted upon his reputation, career, and life by egregiously defending him and unlawfully colluding to blacklist him from the profession to which he has dedicated his life,” the case said.
After Niemann’s upset, Carlsen hinted that wrongdoing had occurred. Niemann, a 19-year-old grandmaster, subsequently said he had cheated in matches on Chess.com when he was 12 and 16 years old — but insisted he had not since then. Carlsen later accused Niemann of having “cheated more — and more recently — than he has publicly admitted.”
In early October, Chess.com released a 72-page report saying Niemann “likely cheated” on its site more frequently than he has publicly acknowledged, and Niemann was banned from the site and online events. At the same time, Chess.com said its investigation failed to turn up an abundance of “concrete statistical evidence” that Niemann cheated in his win over Carlsen.
Niemann’s argument suggests Carlsen wielded his influence as a five-time world champion in a way that has “destroyed Niemann’s remarkable career in its prime and ruined his life.”
Jenkins: When chess is hard and cheating is easy, the next move is complicated
A Norwegian grandmaster, Carlsen won his first world championship in 2013, and later co-founded Play Magnus the same year. Play Magnus began as a chess app which mimicked Carlsen’s playing style at various stages of his life, but has since evolved into a company that offers an online playing site and a book publishing outlet. In August, Play Magnus accepted an acquisition offer by Chess.com worth nearly $83 million.
The lawsuit describes that acquisition as a move that will “monopolize the chess world,” and adds that the partnership inspired Chess.com’s alleged collusion with Carlsen “to blacklist [Niemann] from chess,” as Chess.com and Play Magnus “collectively comprise the majority of FIDE-sanctioned chess tournaments.”
In the wake of Carlsen’s accusations, the argument said, Niemann has had tournament invitations revoked and an upcoming match against 17-year-old German grandmaster Vincent Keymer canceled. It also said Niemann “cannot obtain employment as a chess teacher at a reputable school.”
The lawsuit also names Japanese American grandmaster Hikaru Nakamura, Chess.com’s most popular Twitch streamer with 1.5 million followers. Nakamura is accused of acting in collusion with Carlsen and herss.com by posting videos which it said amplified Carlsen’s cheating against Niemann.
“By design, this sudden ban, at the precise time that Carlsen accused Niemann of cheating against him, added instant credibility to Carlsen’s false and suggested that they were true. Otherwise, there would be no reason for Chess.com to suddenly ban Niemann immediately after he defeated Carlsen,” the litigation claims. “To bolster this unprecedented joint ban, which effectively blacklisted Niemann from professional chess, [grandmaster Hikaru] Nakamura leveraged his platform as Chess.com’s top streamer and credibility as a top chess player to engage in an all-out blitz of defamatory accusations to further confirm that Carlsen accused Niemann of cheating and to make it appear that those accusations are true.”
Chess.com executive Danny Rensch, the final defendant named in the lawsuit, is accusing of issuing “defamatory press releases, and leaked defamatory ‘reports’ to prominent press outlets, falsely accusing Niemann of lying in his post-match Sinquefield Cup interview regarding his use of a ‘chess engine’ in a handful of recreational online games when he was a child,” actions which it said further bolstered Carlsen’s “false” claims.
Per the BBC, lawyers for Chess.com said the found in the argument had “no merit.” In a statement to Polygon, Chess.com’s lawyers noted that “Hans confessed publicly to cheating online in the wake of the Sinquefield Cup, and the resulting fallout is of his own making.”
“As stated in its October 2022 report, Chess.com had historically dealt with Hans’ prior cheating privately, and was forced to clarify its position only after he spoke out publicly. There is no merit to Hans’com, and Chess.com looks forward to setting the record straight on behalf of its team and all honest chess players.”
Carlsen has yet to publicly comment on the argument.